Guestbook of
THE VACATION HOME
OUR GUESTS' THOUGHTS & COMMENTS
DEAR GUESTS, Sadly, your stay with us is over. Doesn't "time fly" when you're having fun?! We hope that you had a splendid time, and that you have come to love Trinity as much as we do! If you have any comments to share about our Vacation Home, we would welcome any you may have as this will be the way in which we can provide you with the best service possible! PLEASE ALSO VIEW THE "COMMENTS" SECTION TO SEE ADDITIONAL FEEDBACK MADE BY GUESTS WHO HAVE STAYED AT COMMANDER'S KEEP. Thank you.
~ David & Catherine Carpenter (Owners)
Written by Lisa Hiscock on Sep. 12, 2016
“Thank you so much for accommodating us in August. We had a very relaxing stay. The property is breathtaking. Very clean, beautiful and convenient location. Our friends loved it as well. Already talking about a returned trip there in the future. We would recommend it to anyone looking for a lovely getaway in Trinity Bight.”
Lisa & Gilbert H.
Written by Lesley on Sep. 7, 2014
“This is a charming, amazing, serene, lovely place with both local hosts and supportive owners who kindly share their home with enthusiasm and hospitality. We had a wonderful week in August 2014.”
Written by Geoff S. on Nov. 11, 2013
“We stayed at CK for four days in the mid fall of 2013. We've been vacationing in Trinity Bight for the past ten years, on a regular basis, and have rented a half dozen other properties in the area, numerous times, over the years. Commander's Keep tops them all. Pure bliss!
Geoff S. & Renee C. St. John's, NL
Written by Leslie & John W. on Oct. 7, 2013
”This was an amazing home for my husband & I to spend a week- plenty of great cooking equipment in the kitchen- nice big coffee mugs, beautiful furnishings, so many small personal details that truly made it feel like a special place. The view off the back deck was gorgeous- gulls flying at eye level- a lighthouse perched on the point into the bay- the lovely little village spread out below the front of the house.
We often stay in vacation homes, this one has exceeded any of them.
Leslie & John Watschke
River Falls, Wisconsin, USA”
Written by Bernd M on Oct. 1, 2013
“A Great Place To Stay”
Reviewed 25 July 2013 for a stay in July 2013 by Bernd M (Deutschland)
Some people say things always look better on photos... in this case reality is just as beautiful.
When we arrived at the house we found that the pictures we based our booking decision on, had not promised too much.
A double-sided fire place divides a cosy living room and a spacious kitchen (equipped with anything you need) and dining area.
The interiour decoration shows great attention to detail and each window offers a nice and sometimes spectacular view - either towards the bay and lighthouse or towards the town.
The water-front patio/deck invited many times to sit down and enjoy a gorgeous scenic view with a cup of coffie or glass of wine. We even got to watch a whale finding his way into the bay.
Not only the kitchen but the entire house is equipped with everything you need and mosquito screens at the windows keep away unwelcome visitors.
We, though, always felt welcome and it was comforting to have a helpful and supporting contact person (the manager of the house) in town.
Written by Andrea & Curtis on Oct. 12, 2015
“We had a fantastic week at Commander's Keep. What a lovely, lovely home and location. Catherine has thought of everything to make you feel at home and comfortable - absolutely everything. She even left us a "happy anniversary" card. The views are BREATHTAKING! LOVED the kitchen. Loved the deck. Loved everything. The only thing that would have made it absolutely perfect would have been a whale sighting (but I was there off season) ... will have to go back in the summer!
Written by K. Family on May. 27, 2022
”Best place to come and relax and spend some must needed family time.”
Written by Sarah & Damion B. on July. 15-18, 2023
”ABSULTLEY STUNING!
We loved it… Beautiful community with so much to see and do. Every day was an adventure beak! Looking forward to coming back“
Thank you..
5/5 Excellent! by Brendan P. 15 Aug 2022 (VRBO)
Front Row Seat
Great adaptation of a traditional saltbox experience with a million dollar view.
“We stayed at CK for four days in the mid fall of 2013. We've been vacationing in Trinity Bight for the past ten years, on a regular basis, and have rented a half dozen other properties in the area, numerous times, over the years. Commander's Keep tops them all. Pure bliss!”
Geoff S. & Renee C.
St. John's, NL.
Written by Lynda K (TripAdvisor on June 26 2023)
Best house, property, location and VIEW on the island. Here’s why!
Simply put. Commander’s Keep is…heaven. Have stayed at CK many times and I cannot recommend the property or location more. The House - Traditional, Cozy, Elegant (clean!). Has absolutely everything you need and more. Location - easy to get to from both Gander and St. John’s. It’s a place you can stay for a few days or 10 days…even weeks. So much to do in the area. The View - not sure there is a better view on the entire island. The Skerwink Trail, The Bay, Icebergs, Whales, Sea otters, The lighthouse (the sound of the lighthouse, late at night as the fog rolls in…eerily relaxing) the Church (and waking up Sunday morning to the sounds of its glorious bells!) Trinity - Rising Tide Theatre - won’t find better community theatre anywhere. 5 stars. Be sure to take in the Trinity Pageant, Dinner Theatre and at least one play. The Restaurants! - Fisher’s Loft, The Twine Loft, Bonavista Social Club and so many more! If it’s a clear day, try to reserve at Fishers Loft (late seating) so you can witness the spectacular sunset. Bonavista Social Club - worth the drive for the sunset alone - BYOB. They do not take reservations. Overall, the town has an abundance of things to do - great shops, restaurants, theatre, hiking trails, iceberg/whale watching tours - you’ll find something new every day and it’s all literally steps from Commander’s Keep! Lastly, the owners and the property managers - You will not find nicer, kinder, sweeter people! They go above and beyond to ensure your stay is perfect! Going to Commanders Keep is like coming home. As soon as you arrive, you’ll walk out onto the incredible deck that floats above the cliff…you’ll look out…and exhale. Heaven.
Written by Maggie T. on Oct. 8, 2013
MaggieTrot
Wisconsin
”Could not have been more perfect!
Left on 10/06/2013 for a stay in September 2013
My husband & I wanted privacy, a view & comfort. It was all included with the extras. We enjoy grocery shopping within the local community & doing our own cooking. The kitchen had plenty of high quality pans, & equipment to make it fun. And nice big coffee & tea mugs! Every window had a lovely view.
The view from the deck was outstanding. We are birders so there was always something to see on the water or flying nearby. The lighthouse directly across the bay finished the picture perfectly. It was difficult to motivate ourselves to get out & explore the local area as we planned, too many delights just sitting on the deck listening to the waves or walking down the long driveway & strolling through the beautiful little village of Trinity.”
Written by Jane H. on Oct. 6, 2013
A Google User
a year ago
”Stayed there this summer - Commander's Keep is the jewel of this beautiful seaside town! Would go back in a heartbeat!”
Written by GORD (SASK.) on Oct. 1, 2013
“COMMANDER'S KEEP: WONDERFUL PROPERTY!”
Reviewed 28 April 2012
Wonderful Property at COMMANDER'S KEEP
Gord (Saskatchewan)
Review submitted: November 27, 2011 Date of arrival: October 14, 2011
Excellent property and all was as advertised. Great 10 day stay. Wonderful views. Absolutely nothing negative to say about property. We were looking for laid back area and experience Newfoundland and found it here. Driving the local area and BonaVista taking all side roads gave us the local flavour. We were late in the season so all pretty quiet. Very limited shopping but only 40 minutes to Clarenville where all available. You should arrive with all your food staples, meat and produce. Although there is a small store and gas available 3 kilometres from the house. Well treated and contact persons live in town and very helpful. Fairly sharp drop 20 feet in front of building, great view but watch the kids. Not a swimming area but this is the rock. Must to have a car. Clean, clean, clean. Would recommend to friends and family if they are looking for a getaway. This is not night club county. Liquor available in most all stores. Dining and wine in quaint atmosphere within walking distance. The entire community is walkable but car required to see anything outside of this community. Would return. GW
Recommended for: age 55+, sight seeing, romantic getaway
• Stayed October 2011, travelled as a couple”
5/5 Excellent. Carly P. 24 Aug 2023 (VRBO)
Absolutely beautiful !
This house was absolutely amazing! The property manager , owners and others were beyond communicative and amazing. The lot is stunning and perfectly nestled in a meadow overlooking the sea harbor where you can no doubt see whales! House has everything you need and more including welcome chocolates from the villages local chocolate and coffee store. The location is superb as you can walk anywhere. I would recommend 10/10
“Thank you so much for accommodating us in August. We had a very relaxing stay. The property is breathtaking. Very clean, beautiful and convenient location. Our friends loved it as well. Already talking about a returned trip there in the future. We would recommend it to anyone looking for a lovely getaway in Trinity Bight”.
Lisa & Gilbert H.